tomo logo

$575,000

Beds
3
Baths
2.0
sq ft
1,823

5261 Highbury Cir, Sarasota, FL 34238

5261 Highbury Cir

SARASOTA, FL 34238

  • <1 day on market
Stunning lake views welcome you as you step into a refreshed and upgraded 3/2 POOL home in the Hamptons, part of Sarasota’s highly sought-after Palmer Ranch. An incredible opportunity awaits as a BRAND-NEW tile roof AND gas water heater have just been installed, ensuring peace of mind for years to come. Upon entering one is greeted by the crowning feature of the home: a long-lake view which can be enjoyed from an expansive paver-decked pool area, the perfect spot from which to take in the soft orange glow of sunset reflecting off the lake, relax on a breezy day, or observe local wildlife, including the beautiful sandhill cranes, a common sight in this part of town. Lush, mature landscaping adds to the aesthetic and ensures privacy as well. The deck has been resealed, and the pool cage re-screened and refinished. The interior, which has just been completely repainted in a fresh, neutral color, in laid out in a smart floor plan with two distinct, separate living spaces are perfect for entertaining guests or for a family to spread out. The living area features soaring cathedral-style ceilings, lending roominess and a bright and airy feel. The remodeled kitchen comes replete with a Bosch gas stove for gourmet cooking and is outfitted with gorgeous quartz counters and soft-close cabinets and drawers. There are upgraded marble counters and glass-enclosed showers in both master and guest baths, a soaking tub in the master, and a beautifully tiled (all the way to the ceiling!) guest step-in shower. This home also includes a whole-house water filtration system and a reverse osmosis filter system for the kitchen. Other upgrades of note include recently installed Levolor easy roll up blinds throughout the home, high-end Hunter Douglas fans, a 2021 HVAC unit, and a freshly coated garage floor. The Hampton’s is a quiet community in the heart of Palmer Ranch, one of Sarasota’s most desirable locations. It is known for its perfect location within touching distance of our world-famous Siesta Key, convenience to shopping, restaurants, and I-75, and its excellent schools. Bikers will also love the proximity to the now extended Legacy Trail. 5261 Highbury is fitting any type of buyer, whether it be snow-birds, young families, or anyone looking to enjoy the good Florida life.

Details

Property type

Single Family Residence

Est. home value

$655,185

Lot size

7,236 sq ft

Price per sq ft

$316

Year built

1999

Annual property taxes

$5,674.08

Monthly HOA fee

$283.85

Price History

04/02/2025
StellarMLS

StellarMLS #A4642539

Listed
$575,000
+6.09%
10/21/2021
StellarMLS

StellarMLS #A4513706

Sold
$542,000

Schools & Community

Elementary school: 

Ashton Elementary

Middle school: 

Sarasota Middle

High school: 

Riverview High

Community features: 

Pool, Sidewalks

Seller’s Loan History

Before you make an offer, understand who you are negotiating with so you can tailor your negotiation strategy to their situation.

Lender

Cendant Mortgage Corp

Loan start date

May 2001

Original loan amount

$168,900

Est. remaining balance

Not provided

Interest rate

6.91%

Loan type

New Conventional

Seller

Louis E Diefenbach and Carol Diefenbach

Lender

P H H Mtg Svc

Loan start date

January 2000

Original loan amount

$163,562

Est. remaining balance

Not provided

Interest rate

7.84%

Loan type

Not Provided

Seller

Louis E Diefenbach and Carol Diefenbach

Source: Public records data

If you're the owner, you can request to remove loan details. Email listingsupport@tomo.com

How insights can help you

Interest rate

If the seller has a low interest rate, they may be tempted to rent the property out if they can't get the price they have in mind.

Motivation

If the seller already got a job in a different city, they may feel pressure to sell quickly to free up cash for a new home.

Equity

If the seller stands to receive a large amount of cash when they sell the property, they might be willing to negotiate on the offer price.

Interested in learning more?

Status: Active

Tomo last checked: 04/03/2025 at 7:55 AM

Listing updated: 04/03/2025 at 6:58 AM

Listed by: Adam Kwiat, RE/MAX PLATINUM REALTY Phone #: (941) 929-9090

MLS: StellarMLS #A4642539

StellarMLS logo

Recently listed in SARASOTA

$599,000|3 bd|2.0 ba|House
$2,750,000|4 bd|5.0 ba|House
$412,500|3 bd|2.5 ba|Townhouse
$495,000|3 bd|2.0 ba|House
$650,000|5 bd|3.0 ba|House
$575,000|3 bd|2.0 ba|House
$899,000|5 bd|3.0 ba|House
$850,000|5 bd|3.0 ba|House
$769,000|4 bd|3.0 ba|House