tomo logo

$3,950,000

Beds
4
Baths
3.5
sq ft
4,314

851 Georgia Ave, Winter Park, FL 32789

851 Georgia Ave

WINTER PARK, FL 32789

  • 1 day on market
Nestled on a sprawling 0.89-acre estate, this luxurious home offers the perfect balance of privacy and convenience, just moments from the vibrant downtown Winter Park. A rare gem, this 1935 James Gamble Rogers masterpiece blends Old World charm with European influences, creating an inviting, character-rich ambiance. The main home features 3 bedrooms, 2 1/2 bathrooms, and 3,908 square feet of elegant living space, complemented by a 1-bedroom, 1-bathroom guest cottage, adding 406 square feet, for a total of 4,314 square feet. Accessed via a long, secluded driveway, this estate seamlessly blends indoor and outdoor living with lush gardens, expansive courtyards, and tranquil patios. Inside, arched doorways, reclaimed doors, and rounded stucco walls evoke a Santa Barbara Mediterranean feel. The kitchen is outfitted with stainless steel appliances, granite countertops, and a butler’s pantry—ideal for entertaining. The formal dining room opens to a living room with a curved barrel ceiling, a fireplace, and French doors leading to a garden patio. A sunlit sunroom offers panoramic garden and pool views, perfect for relaxation. The expansive downstairs owner's suite features vaulted ceilings, French doors to the patio, a cozy fireplace, and a lavish marble bath with a Jacuzzi tub, double sinks, and a dressing area with custom cabinetry and two large walk-in closets. Upstairs, two bedrooms share a beautifully renovated marble bath. The detached 2-car garage is adjacent to the laundry room, while the guest house offers a studio layout with terra-cotta floors, a kitchenette, a full bath, and French doors overlooking the pool. The backyard is an oasis of tranquility with a stunning resort-style pool, an expansive patio, and lush landscaping, providing ultimate privacy. This home offers the best of both worlds: a rare opportunity to own a piece of Winter Park history, yet lovingly maintained with modern updates and conveniences throughout.

Details

Property type

Single Family Residence

Est. home value

$3,906,696

Lot size

0.89 acres

Price per sq ft

$916

Year built

1935

Annual property taxes

$28,625

HOA

No

Price History

03/20/2025
StellarMLS

StellarMLS #O6291851

Listed
$3,950,000
+110.67%
10/16/2013
StellarMLS

StellarMLS #O5134211

Sold
$1,875,000

Schools & Community

Elementary school: 

Lakemont Elem

Middle school: 

Maitland Middle

High school: 

Winter Park High

Negotiation Insights

Before you make an offer, understand who you are negotiating with so you can tailor your negotiation strategy to their situation.

Seller could get up to

$2,790,938
Asking price
$3,950,000
Closing costs (~8% of asking)
-$316,000
Est. remaining loan balance
-$843,062
Cash to seller
$2,790,938

This is an estimate of how much the seller could receive at closing after paying off the outstanding mortgage.

Seller’s Loan History

Lender

Wells Fargo Bank Na

Loan start date

October 2021

Original loan amount

$910,000

Est. remaining balance

$843,062

Interest rate

2.87%

Loan type

New Conventional, 30 year

Seller

John F Kelly and Margaret A Kelly

Source: Public records data

If you're the owner, you can request to remove loan details. Email listingsupport@tomo.com

How insights can help you

Interest rate

If the seller has a low interest rate, they may be tempted to rent the property out if they can't get the price they have in mind.

Motivation

If the seller already got a job in a different city, they may feel pressure to sell quickly to free up cash for a new home.

Equity

If the seller stands to receive a large amount of cash when they sell the property, they might be willing to negotiate on the offer price.

Interested in learning more?

Status: Active

Tomo last checked: 03/22/2025 at 6:00 AM

Listing updated: 03/21/2025 at 5:49 PM

Listed by: Nancy Bagby, FANNIE HILLMAN & ASSOCIATES Phone #: (407) 644-1234

MLS: StellarMLS #O6291851

StellarMLS logo

Recently listed in WINTER PARK