tomo logo

$835,750

Beds
3
Baths
2.5
sq ft
Unknown

91 S Penataquit Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

91 S Penataquit Ave

Bay Shore, NY 11706

  • 15 days on market
    • Open house Apr 06
In Times of uncertainty why not buy yourself ANY certainty? This will never change. Location is the best. Excellent school district. BRICK HOUSE RENOVATED DOWN TO THE STUDS & condition is brand new, unreal low taxes for .7 acres), room to grow. 2nd floor?? Year round vacation living. BAY SHORE SCHOOL DISTRICT’s BEST VALUE! In over a year South of Montauk have not come together for less than a million plus. NEW construction architecturally designed by one of Bayshores finest! On the highly sought after Penataquit Peninsula. Sprawling views with sunny open floor pan and cathedral ceilings. EIK with a 14 foot quartz island, stainless modern kitchen. Formal dining room, GREEN FEATURES INCLUDE NEW ROOF, SIDING , WINDOWS, kitchen, bathrooms , INSULATION , SHEETROCK, ELECTRICAL SYSTEM , DUCTLESS AC KITCHEN, BATHROOMS , HOT WATER ON DEMAND HEATER, CAT 5 INTERNET, AND MORE. 3 bedroom with a playroom/ office and 3 Bath (240 sq ft primary bedroom with new en suite, cathedral ceilings, 14 feet of closets for 2, cathedral ceilings & a sliding glass door out to your 500 foot patio and pool). Amazing sunrise view and sunsets. 2.5 bathrooms with 3 Restoration Hardware medicine cabinets & lighting that stay. APPROXIMATELY $12,800 with star rebate. LOW FLOOD (approx. $2k) due to great 75 year history of 3 floods. Boat dockage 4 houses South. We get to Fire Island in 15 minutes. Semi in ground Pool allows you with proper permits to have a pool cabana house in 2 car detached garage. And that’s why this is Bayshore’s best value!! Its so relaxing sitting on the water and surrounded by forests.

Details

Property type

Single Family Residence

Lot size

0.67 acres

Price per sq ft

Unknown

Year built

1952

Annual property taxes

$14,404

Price History

03/19/2025
OneKey

OneKey #837860

Listed
$835,750
+439.19%
06/28/2016
OneKey

OneKey #2829744

Sold
$155,000
-38%
05/21/2014
OneKey

OneKey #2623199

Sold
$250,000

Schools & Community

Neighborhood: 

Bay Shore

Elementary school: 

Contact Agent

Middle school: 

Bay Shore Middle School

High school: 

Bay Shore Senior High School

High school district: 

Bay Shore

Status: Active

Tomo last checked: 04/03/2025 at 12:45 PM

Listing updated: 04/02/2025 at 6:06 PM

Listed by: Matthew Hart, World Prop Intl Sea to Sky Phone #: (631) 961-4626

MLS: OneKey #837860

OneKey logo

Recently listed in Bay Shore

$549,999|3 bd|2.0 ba|House
$615,000|3 bd|2.0 ba|House
$650,000|4 bd|1.0 ba|House
$640,000|4 bd|2.0 ba|House
$510,000|3 bd|1.0 ba|House
$525,000|4 bd|2.5 ba|House
$649,990|2 bd|2.5 ba|Condo
$629,500|3 bd|2.0 ba|House
$619,999|3 bd|2.0 ba|House
$348,888|3 bd|1.0 ba|House