tomo logo

$1,275,000

Beds
3
Baths
2.5
sq ft
2,036

1951 Sheffield Ave, Marco Island, FL 34145

1951 Sheffield Ave

Marco Island, FL 34145

  • 1 day on market
Step into this stunning 2023 custom-built home, contemporary design and smart construction blend seamlessly. Elevated 17 feet and built with concrete block, a durable metal roof, and high-impact windows and doors, this home offers both security and peace of mind—ideal for Florida living. Plus, enjoy the added bonus of a remarkably low flood insurance rate! Inside, soaring tray ceilings and an open floor plan create a bright, airy atmosphere, perfect for effortless living and entertaining. The oversized screened-in lanai with a luxurious spa provides the ultimate retreat for relaxation or hosting guests. Need extra space? The massive 2,000-square-foot garage and storage area downstairs offer endless possibilities. This unique 3-bedroom home also features a private office, 2.5 beautifully designed bathrooms, and a spacious primary suite with an extra-large closet for ultimate convenience. Every detail has been thoughtfully designed for comfort and style. Motivated sellers—bring your offers!

Details

Property type

Single Family Residence

Lot size

0.27 acres

Price per sq ft

$627

Year built

2023

Annual property taxes

$9,155.28

HOA

No

Price History

03/22/2025

FGCMLS #225029984

Listed
$1,275,000
-5.56%
03/21/2025

FGCMLS #224095709

Removed
$1,350,000
02/28/2025

FGCMLS #224095709

Price change
$1,350,000
-9.94%

Schools & Community

Elementary school: 

Unknown

Middle school: 

Unknown

High school: 

Unknown

Number of units in community: 

1

Seller’s Loan History

Before you make an offer, understand who you are negotiating with so you can tailor your negotiation strategy to their situation.

Lender

Lake Michigan Cu

Loan start date

June 2021

Original loan amount

$425,000

Est. remaining balance

Not provided

Interest rate

3.04%

Loan type

Building or Construction Loan, 30 year

Seller

Mark Thiel and Tamara Thiel

Source: Public records data

If you're the owner, you can request to remove loan details. Email listingsupport@tomo.com

How insights can help you

Interest rate

If the seller has a low interest rate, they may be tempted to rent the property out if they can't get the price they have in mind.

Motivation

If the seller already got a job in a different city, they may feel pressure to sell quickly to free up cash for a new home.

Equity

If the seller stands to receive a large amount of cash when they sell the property, they might be willing to negotiate on the offer price.

Interested in learning more?

Status: Active

Tomo last checked: 03/24/2025 at 12:00 AM

Listing updated: 03/22/2025 at 2:25 PM

Listed by: Siobhan St Amour, Coldwell Banker Realty Phone #: (239) 394-8121

MLS: FGCMLS #225029984

FGCMLS logo

Recently listed in Marco Island